Providing uncertainty with Measurements.jl

Measurements.jl provides automatic error propagation, and integrates seamlessly with much of the Julia ecosystem.

Here, we'll slightly modify the Daisyworld example, to simulate some measurement uncertainty in our world's parameters.

Setup

First we'll construct our agents.

using Agents
using Measurements

@agent Daisy GridAgent{2} begin
    breed::Symbol
    age::Int
    albedo::AbstractFloat # Allow Measurements
end

@agent Land GridAgent{2} begin
    temperature::AbstractFloat # Allow Measurements
end

Notice that there is only one small difference between this version and the original example model: the use of AbstractFloat instead of Float64 for the albedo and temperature parameters. Behaviour between these two types is practically equivalent from our perspective, but it allows us to use an uncertain value for our two parameters. 1.0 ± 0.1 rather than 1.0 for example. We could also be specific here and bind the parameters with type Measurement{Float64} as well.

Next, we'll implement all the important functions for DaisyWorld. If you want to know what each of these functions do, see the Daisyworld example, as they are copied directly from there.

using CairoMakie
using Statistics: mean
import DrWatson: @dict
import StatsBase

const DaisyWorld = ABM{<:GridSpace,Union{Daisy,Land}}

function update_surface_temperature!(pos::Dims{2}, model::DaisyWorld)
    ids = ids_in_position(pos, model)
    absorbed_luminosity = if length(ids) == 1
        (1 - model.surface_albedo) * model.solar_luminosity
    else
        (1 - model[ids[2]].albedo) * model.solar_luminosity
    end
    local_heating = absorbed_luminosity > 0 ? 72 * log(absorbed_luminosity) + 80 : 80
    T0 = model[ids[1]].temperature
    model[ids[1]].temperature = (T0 + local_heating) / 2
end

function diffuse_temperature!(pos::Dims{2}, model::DaisyWorld)
    ratio = get(model.properties, :ratio, 0.5)
    ids = nearby_ids(pos, model)
    meantemp = sum(model[i].temperature for i in ids if model[i] isa Land) / 8
    land = model[ids_in_position(pos, model)[1]]
    land.temperature = (1 - ratio) * land.temperature + ratio * meantemp
end

function propagate!(pos::Dims{2}, model::DaisyWorld)
    ids = ids_in_position(pos, model)
    if length(ids) > 1
        daisy = model[ids[2]]
        temperature = model[ids[1]].temperature
        seed_threshold = (0.1457 * temperature - 0.0032 * temperature^2) - 0.6443
        if rand(model.rng) < seed_threshold
            filter_place_daisy(pos) = length(ids_in_position(pos, model)) == 1
            seeding_place = random_nearby_position(pos, model, 1, filter_place_daisy)
            if !isnothing(seeding_place)
                a = Daisy(nextid(model), seeding_place, daisy.breed, 0, daisy.albedo)
                add_agent_pos!(a, model)
            end
        end
    end
end

function agent_step!(agent::Daisy, model::DaisyWorld)
    agent.age += 1
    agent.age >= model.max_age && remove_agent!(agent, model)
end

agent_step!(agent::Land, model::DaisyWorld) = nothing

function model_step!(model)
    for p in positions(model)
        update_surface_temperature!(p, model)
        diffuse_temperature!(p, model)
        propagate!(p, model)
    end
    model.tick += 1
    solar_activity!(model)
end

function solar_activity!(model::DaisyWorld)
    if model.scenario == :ramp
        if model.tick > 200 && model.tick <= 400
            model.solar_luminosity += model.solar_change
        end
        if model.tick > 500 && model.tick <= 750
            model.solar_luminosity -= model.solar_change / 2
        end
    elseif model.scenario == :change
        model.solar_luminosity += model.solar_change
    end
end

solar_activity! (generic function with 1 method)

Adding Uncertainty

Now, we can write a constructor function, and use uncertainly values which will propagate automatically through our model.

function daisyworld(;
    griddims = (30, 30),
    max_age = 25,
    init_white = 0.2,
    init_black = 0.2,
    albedo_white = 0.75,
    albedo_black = 0.25,
    # Surface albedo measurements are complicated for our satellites perhaps
    surface_albedo = 0.4 ± 0.15,
    # Measurements from the sun are generally stable, but fluctuate around 10%
    solar_change = 0.005 ± 0.002,
    solar_luminosity = 1.0 ± 0.1,
    scenario = :default,
)

    space = GridSpace(griddims)
    properties = @dict max_age surface_albedo solar_luminosity solar_change scenario
    properties[:tick] = 0
    daisysched(model) = [a.id for a in allagents(model) if a isa Daisy]
    model = ABM(
        Union{Daisy,Land},
        space;
        scheduler = daisysched,
        properties = properties,
        warn = false,
    )

    # An uncertain initial temperature, solely for type stability
    fill_space!(Land, model, 0.0 ± 0.0)
    grid = collect(positions(model))
    num_positions = prod(griddims)
    white_positions =
        StatsBase.sample(grid, Int(init_white * num_positions); replace = false)
    for wp in white_positions
        wd = Daisy(nextid(model), wp, :white, rand(model.rng, 0:max_age), albedo_white)
        add_agent_pos!(wd, model)
    end
    allowed = setdiff(grid, white_positions)
    black_positions =
        StatsBase.sample(allowed, Int(init_black * num_positions); replace = false)
    for bp in black_positions
        wd = Daisy(nextid(model), bp, :black, rand(model.rng, 0:max_age), albedo_black)
        add_agent_pos!(wd, model)
    end

    return model
end

daisyworld (generic function with 1 method)

You see we've included uncertainty in four places: surface albedo and initial temperature, and the two solar luminosity values. We do not require changes to any model code, nor handle these parameters in any special way; for example 2.0 * surface_albedo is a regular operation. Errors will be propagated under the hood automatically.

Visualizing the Result

Similar to the Daisyworld example, we will now check out how the surface temperature and daisy count fares when solar luminosity ramps up.

First, some helper functions

black(a) = a.breed == :black
white(a) = a.breed == :white
daisies(a) = a isa Daisy

land(a) = a isa Land
adata = [(black, count, daisies), (white, count, daisies), (:temperature, mean, land)]

mdata = [:solar_luminosity]

1-element Vector{Symbol}:
 :solar_luminosity

And now the simulation

model = daisyworld(scenario = :ramp)
agent_df, model_df =
    run!(model, agent_step!, model_step!, 1000; adata = adata, mdata = mdata)

f = Figure(resolution = (600, 800))
ax = f[1, 1] = Axis(f, ylabel = "Daisy count", title = "Daisyworld Analysis")
lb = lines!(ax, agent_df.step, agent_df.count_black_daisies, linewidth = 2, color = :blue)
lw = lines!(ax, agent_df.step, agent_df.count_white_daisies, linewidth = 2, color = :red)
leg =
    f[1, 1] = Legend(
        f,
        [lb, lw],
        ["black", "white"],
        tellheight = false,
        tellwidth = false,
        halign = :right,
        valign = :top,
        margin = (10, 10, 10, 10),
    )

ax2 = f[2, 1] = Axis(f, ylabel = "Temperature")
highband =
    Measurements.value.(agent_df[!, dataname(adata[3])]) +
    Measurements.uncertainty.(agent_df[!, dataname(adata[3])])
lowband =
    Measurements.value.(agent_df[!, dataname(adata[3])]) -
    Measurements.uncertainty.(agent_df[!, dataname(adata[3])])
band!(ax2, agent_df.step, lowband, highband, color = (:steelblue, 0.5))
lines!(
    ax2,
    agent_df.step,
    Measurements.value.(agent_df[!, dataname(adata[3])]),
    linewidth = 2,
    color = :blue,
)

ax3 = f[3, 1] = Axis(f, ylabel = "Luminosity")
highband =
    Measurements.value.(model_df.solar_luminosity) +
    Measurements.uncertainty.(model_df.solar_luminosity)
lowband =
    Measurements.value.(model_df.solar_luminosity) -
    Measurements.uncertainty.(model_df.solar_luminosity)
band!(ax3, agent_df.step, lowband, highband, color = (:steelblue, 0.5))
lines!(
    ax3,
    agent_df.step,
    Measurements.value.(model_df.solar_luminosity),
    linewidth = 2,
    color = :blue,
)
f